How to Choose GA or GI: Galvannealed and Hot Dip Galvanized Coil Compared

Aug 19, 2025 Leave a message

What GA and GI Actually Are

The two abbreviations describe two different coatings produced on the same continuous hot dip line, and the distinction is chemical, not commercial. GI is hot dip galvanized steel: the strip passes through a molten zinc bath at around 450-460 °C and leaves with a coating that is essentially metallic zinc. GA is galvannealed steel: after the same zinc bath, the coated strip passes directly into an in-line annealing furnace that holds it at roughly 500-550 °C for a few seconds, allowing iron from the steel substrate to diffuse into the coating. The result is a zinc-iron alloy coating containing typically around 8-12 % iron, with a matte grey appearance instead of the bright spangle of GI.

Both are hot dip products. Neither is electrolytic, and neither is an aluminium-zinc coating. The substrates are ordered to the same family of standards: EN 10346, where GA is written with the +ZF suffix and GI with +Z, and ASTM A653, where galvannealed coatings carry an A designation such as A60 and galvanized coatings a G designation such as G60 or G90. Confusing the two with aluminium-zinc products, which are covered by ASTM A792 and use an entirely different bath chemistry, is a frequent and expensive error.

Corrosion Behaviour and Salt Spray Performance

GI protects steel sacrificially: zinc is anodic to iron, so where the coating is scratched the zinc around the scratch corrodes first and the exposed steel is protected. This is why GI performs well where the surface will be cut, drilled or damaged in service. Its weakness is that plain zinc corrodes relatively quickly in the early stages of exposure, producing white zinc corrosion product before the protective carbonate film stabilizes.

GA protects by a different balance. The zinc-iron alloy is harder and less sacrificial, but the coating is more resistant to early attack, and because it contains significant iron it takes paint readily and holds it under deformation. In neutral salt spray testing to ASTM B117, a zinc-iron coating generally resists the onset of white corrosion substantially longer than a plain zinc coating of comparable coating mass. ASTM B117 itself is a test practice and does not specify pass or fail hours; the acceptance figure has to be agreed between purchaser and supplier for the specific coating mass and product. Any comparison between two products is only meaningful when coating mass, surface treatment and sample preparation are identical.

Comparison for Specification Purposes

Attribute GI (hot dip zinc) GA (galvannealed, zinc-iron)
Coating composition essentially pure zinc zinc with roughly 8-12 % iron
Surface bright, spangled, smooth matte, grey, micro-rough
Paint adhesion requires surface treatment for good keying excellent mechanical keying, standard for painting
Sacrificial protection at cut edges strong reduced, because the alloy is less anodic
Welding behaviour zinc vaporizes, electrode wear and porosity higher better, because the coating melts at a higher temperature
Forming and friction softer coating, lower friction, susceptible to galling harder coating, higher friction, must be lubricated for drawing
Heat resistance limited by zinc behaviour better, because the alloy layer is already formed
Relative cost lower higher, because of the additional in-line annealing step

The hardness of the GA coating has a second consequence that is often overlooked: because the alloy is abrasive, it wears tooling faster than GI does in blanking and forming, and the lubrication schedule normally has to be reviewed when a line changes from GI to GA substrate.

Selection Rules

Choose GI when the part will be exposed to weather with cut edges and drilled holes, when the surface will remain unpainted, when the required bending and forming is severe without heavy lubrication provisions, and when first cost is the controlling factor. Pressure plates, brackets, purlins, guard rails, cable trays and general fabrication all fall into this group.

Choose GA when the coil will be prepainted, because the micro-rough surface gives the primer a mechanical key that survives bending and hemming far better than a paint system applied over smooth zinc. Automotive bodies, appliance panels, door skins and architectural cladding are the classic applications. Choose GA as well when the part is welded in high volume, because the lower zinc vapour generation reduces porosity and electrode consumption, and when the part sees elevated temperature in service, since the alloy layer is more stable than plain zinc.

Two practical cautions. GA is not a substitute for GI at bare cut edges, so designs that rely on sacrificial protection of a large cut area should stay with GI or apply a repair coating. Conversely GI is rarely the right substrate under a demanding paint system without a conversion coating, so a decision to save cost by switching a painted product from GA to GI usually fails at the adhesion test rather than at the corrosion test.

Ordering Details That Change the Outcome

Whichever coating is chosen, four items should be stated on the order beyond the grade: coating mass per unit area for both faces, coating type including the suffix, surface treatment or passivation, and oiling condition. Coating mass positions the product in the corrosion life table; the suffix decides whether the coating is zinc or zinc-iron; passivation decides how the coil behaves in storage; and the oil film decides friction in the press. Two coils that look identical may differ on all four points, and it is these four that determine whether the delivered material behaves as expected on the line.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is GA simply galvanized steel with a different name?
A: No. GA is galvannealed steel, produced by annealing the freshly galvanized coating so that iron diffuses into it and forms a zinc-iron alloy. The coating chemistry, surface appearance, welding behaviour and paint response all differ from plain galvanized product.

Q: Which is more corrosion resistant, GI or GA?
A: It depends on the exposure. GA resists the early onset of corrosion better and takes paint far better, which is decisive for painted parts. GI provides stronger sacrificial protection at cut edges and scratches, which is decisive for unpainted parts that will be damaged in service.

Q: Why does GA weld better than GI?
A: The zinc-iron alloy coating melts at a higher temperature than plain zinc and releases less zinc vapour into the arc. Less vapour means less porosity and less contamination of the electrode tip, so weld quality and electrode life both improve.

Q: Can GA be used outdoors without painting?
A: It can, but its main advantage is realized under a paint system. Unpainted GA has a matte grey appearance and less sacrificial protection at cut edges than GI, so for exposed structural work GI is usually the more durable choice.

Q: Does a salt spray hour figure come from the standard?
A: No. ASTM B117 defines how the test is conducted, not the acceptance limit. The required hours and the permitted corrosion rating must be agreed for the specific product and coating mass, and results are only comparable between samples tested under identical conditions.

Q: Does the choice of coating change the press settings?
A: Yes. The harder zinc-iron coating on GA increases friction and tool wear compared with GI, so lubricant selection and die maintenance intervals normally have to be reviewed whenever the substrate is changed.