Zinc Layer Defects on Galvanized Coil: Types, Causes and Process Countermeasures

Aug 05, 2025 Leave a message

Zinc layer defects on galvanized coil are rarely random. Flaking, thickness variation, score marks, staining and out-of-spec tensile results each map back to a defined window in the annealing furnace, the zinc pot or the post-treatment line, and each one can be traced with the process data the line already records.

Reading a Coating Defect Correctly

The first step is to separate appearance from performance. Surface appearance is assessed against the finish designations of ASTM A653/A653M, where finish A is normal spangle, finish B is minimised spangle and finish C is smooth or spangle-free. Coating mass and its tolerances are specified under ASTM A924/A924M and measured gravimetrically to ASTM A90/A90M or EN ISO 1460. A coil can show an unattractive spangle pattern while fully meeting its coating mass class, and equally a coil with a uniform appearance can fail adhesion. Defect classification should state which of the two is in question before any corrective action is agreed.

Flaking and Loss of Adhesion

Flaking appears as coating that lifts from the substrate during bending, stamping or even handling, exposing bare steel. Three process causes dominate. The first is annealing atmosphere control: insufficient hydrogen purity or a dew point that is too high leaves an oxide film on the strip surface, and the zinc cannot form a continuous bond with an oxidised surface. The second is aluminium content in the zinc melt. Aluminium controls formation of the Fe-Al transition layer that anchors the coating, and the working window is normally held between 0.15 and 0.25 percent; below that window the alloy layer becomes discontinuous and adhesion drops.

The third cause is thermal history of the substrate. Heavy work hardening from cold rolling that is not fully relieved in the annealing furnace leaves residual stress at the coating interface, and that stress releases at the first forming operation. The diagnostic is straightforward: if flaking follows forming, check substrate hardness and annealing temperature; if it appears straight off the line, check dew point and bath aluminium first.

Uneven Coating Thickness Across the Strip

Thickness variation that exceeds the tolerance of the coating class shows up later as uneven corrosion, because coating life scales with local zinc mass. The dominant cause is air knife setup. Unequal pressure on the two sides, or a knife-to-strip distance that varies across the width, produces a transverse profile with a heavy centre and light edges or the reverse. Strip speed is the second variable: acceleration and deceleration change the amount of zinc wiped from the surface, so coating mass measured at the head and tail of a coil can differ from the steady-state value in the middle.

Zinc pot level instability adds a third source. A fluctuating bath level changes the immersion geometry and the amount of zinc carried out of the pot, and the effect becomes visible as a longitudinal wave in coating mass. Control practice is to log air knife pressure, knife gap, line speed and pot level against the coating mass measurement, so that any deviation can be attributed to a single variable rather than to the process as a whole.

Scratches and Score Marks

Linear marks along the rolling direction are classified by depth. Shallow marks disturb only the zinc layer and remain a cosmetic and corrosion issue; deep marks reach the substrate and are a structural concern at the affected location. The cause chain starts upstream: substrate scratched by rolls or guides during cold rolling and not detected at that stage, sharp foreign matter such as iron fines on a furnace roll or in the galvanizing line, or interlayer friction during coiling when tension is set too high.

Because the mark is transferred rather than created at the last stage, the corrective action is normally found several stands upstream of where the defect is discovered. Checking roll condition and cleaning practice at the furnace and the line entry resolves the majority of recurring score marks.

Oxidative Staining: Yellow and Blue Spots

Yellow, blue or grey streaks after annealing or galvanizing are oxide films rather than coating defects in the usual sense. They form when the annealing furnace dew point rises above roughly minus 40 degrees Celsius or when residual oxygen is present, when the strip cools too slowly after the zinc pot so that the coating reacts with air while still hot, or when the passivation solution concentration or the drying temperature in post-treatment is insufficient and the coating is left exposed to humid air.

Staining that reappears in the same position on successive coils usually indicates a mechanical or thermal gradient rather than a chemistry problem: the section of the strip that cools slowest or that passes closest to a hot surface is the one that oxidises. Recording position along the strip, not just the appearance, is what makes the cause visible.

Out-of-Spec Mechanical Properties

Tensile results that miss the grade limits affect formability in the customer's press rather than the coating itself, but the two are often reported together. Yield strength above specification with low elongation points to insufficient annealing temperature or holding time, so that work hardening from cold rolling is not fully removed. Excessively coarse grain from an over-high annealing temperature or an aggressive cooling rate raises brittleness and lowers uniform elongation. Substrate chemistry outside the grade window, particularly carbon and manganese above the limits of the base standard, makes the annealing response unpredictable and prevents the line from holding properties within a narrow band.

Defect Primary process cause First variable to check
Coating flaking Oxidised substrate or low bath aluminium Dew point and hydrogen purity; Al 0.15 - 0.25 %
Uneven coating mass Air knife imbalance or speed variation Knife pressure both sides; knife gap
Score marks Roll condition and foreign matter Furnace and line rolls; coiling tension
Yellow or blue stain Oxidation after pot or in post-treatment Cooling rate; passivation concentration
Low elongation Incomplete annealing Annealing temperature and hold time
Coarse grain and brittleness Over-high annealing or fast cooling Cooling curve; substrate carbon

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why does the zinc layer flake off during bending?
A: Flaking during forming usually means the bond between coating and substrate was never complete, caused by an oxidised strip surface from a high annealing dew point or by zinc bath aluminium below the 0.15 to 0.25 percent working window.

Q: What causes coating mass to vary across the strip width?
A: Most commonly air knife pressure imbalance or a knife-to-strip distance that changes across the width. Strip speed changes during acceleration and deceleration are the second cause, affecting coating mass along the length.

Q: Are yellow and blue spots a coating quality defect?
A: They are oxide films on the zinc surface rather than a change in coating mass. They arise from a high annealing dew point, slow cooling after the zinc pot, or insufficient passivation or drying in post-treatment.

Q: How should score marks be investigated?
A: By classifying depth first. Shallow marks affect only the coating; deep marks reach the substrate. The cause is usually a roll or foreign matter upstream of where the defect is seen, so the line entry and furnace rolls are checked first.

Q: What makes tensile properties fall outside the specified range?
A: Annealing temperature and holding time control the balance of strength and elongation. Insufficient annealing leaves work hardening in place, while excessive temperature or fast cooling produces coarse grain and lower ductility.

Q: Which standards define coating mass and its tolerances?
A: Coating mass is measured to ASTM A90/A90M or EN ISO 1460, thickness by the magnetic method in EN ISO 2178, and general coating tolerances for continuously coated sheet are defined in ASTM A924/A924M.