SGCC vs SECC: Hot-Dip Galvanized and Electrogalvanized Steel Compared

Jun 13, 2025 Leave a message

Direct Answer: SGCC and SECC Are Not the Same Material

SGCC and SECC are both zinc-coated cold-rolled steel sheets, but they are produced by different coating processes and are therefore specified for different duties. SGCC is a hot-dip galvanized sheet defined in the Japanese standard JIS G3302, with a pure zinc coating by default. SECC is an electrogalvanized sheet defined in JIS G3313, where zinc is deposited electrolytically from a solution. The two designations are sometimes treated as interchangeable in purchasing conversations, but the coating structure, thickness, surface appearance and corrosion performance differ enough that substituting one for the other changes the life of the finished part.

Comparison of the Two Products

Feature SGCC - hot-dip galvanized SECC - electrogalvanized
Standard JIS G3302 JIS G3313
Coating formation Immersion in molten zinc, alloy layer at the interface Electrolytic deposition of zinc from solution
Typical coating thickness About 8 to 20 µm per side for common Z120 to Z275 coatings, with heavier coatings available About 2.5 to 10 µm per side for normal commercial coatings; thinner and more uniform
Corrosion resistance Very good; suited to outdoor and structural parts Moderate; suited to indoor, painted and appearance-critical parts
Surface appearance Visible zinc spangle, slightly rougher Smooth and uniform, no spangle
Formability and welding Formable, but welding and tight forming of heavy coatings need care Excellent stamping, bending and welding behaviour
Relative cost Lower cost per unit of coating mass, high zinc consumption but a simple line Higher cost, driven by electrolysis energy and process control
Typical use Building panels, purlins, ducts, outdoor housings, irrigation hardware Electrical enclosures, appliance shells, automotive inner panels, painted casings

Why the Coating Process Creates the Difference

In hot-dip galvanizing, the strip enters a molten zinc bath at roughly 450 to 460 degrees Celsius, so iron and zinc interdiffuse and a zinc-iron alloy layer forms at the interface. That metallurgical bond gives strong adhesion and a substantial zinc reservoir that protects cut edges and scratches by sacrificial action over a long period. The visible spangle is a natural result of zinc solidification, and the surface is usually slightly rougher than an electrogalvanized surface.

In electrogalvanizing, zinc is deposited at ambient temperature from an electrolyte. There is no alloy layer and no molten-metal dwell time, so the coating can be made extremely thin and uniform, and the surface stays smooth. The trade-off is a smaller zinc reservoir: less sacrificial capacity at a cut edge and a shorter time to red rust in aggressive conditions.

Grade Equivalents in Other Systems

SGCC is a commercial-quality hot-dip galvanized cold-rolled sheet and is roughly equivalent to DX51D+Z under EN 10346 and to ASTM A653 CS Type B in the United States, where CS stands for commercial steel. The same DX51D+Z designation covers the general Chinese and European commercial hot-dip galvanized grade. SECC, being electrogalvanized, is closer to EN 10152 electrolytically zinc-coated grades such as DC01+ZE and to ASTM A879 commercial-quality electrolytic zinc-coated sheet. Korean producers commonly adopt the Japanese designations directly, so SGCC and SECC appear widely across Asian supply chains.

How to Choose Between Them

Choose SGCC where the part faces moisture, outdoor weather or wash-down, where cut edges and fixing holes must resist corrosion, or where a long maintenance interval matters more than surface perfection.

Choose SECC where the part is painted or coated and appearance is critical, where deep drawing or complex stamping is required, where welding quality must be consistent, or where the assembly is used indoors in a controlled environment.

Consider a duplex system where the highest durability is needed: a hot-dip galvanized substrate with a phosphate and paint or powder coating gives the corrosion reserve of zinc plus the barrier of the organic layer.

Two practical points often decide the question on the shop floor. First, coating mass rather than process name governs service life in a given environment, so compare the declared zinc mass in g/m² on both sides before comparing prices. Second, formability and weldability limits come from the coating: heavy spangled coatings may need larger bend radii and a specific welding procedure, while thin electrogalvanized coatings are more forgiving in high-speed press lines.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is SGCC the same as SECC?
No. SGCC is hot-dip galvanized to JIS G3302 and SECC is electrogalvanized to JIS G3313, so coating thickness, surface finish, corrosion life and processing behaviour all differ.

Q: Which has better corrosion resistance, SGCC or SECC?
SGCC, because its hot-dip coating is usually far heavier. SECC relies on a thinner, smoother coating and is normally chosen for indoor or painted applications.

Q: What is SGCC equivalent to in other standards?
It corresponds broadly to DX51D+Z under EN 10346 and to ASTM A653 CS Type B, and the same designation is used for the Chinese commercial hot-dip galvanized grade.

Q: What is SECC equivalent to?
As an electrogalvanized sheet it corresponds to EN 10152 grades such as DC01+ZE and to ASTM A879 commercial-quality electrolytic zinc-coated steel.

Q: Can SECC be used outdoors?
Only for mildly exposed or painted parts. For continuous outdoor exposure or frequent wash-down, a hot-dip galvanized grade with a heavier coating is the safer specification.

Q: Does the spangle on SGCC affect its performance?
No. Spangle is a cosmetic feature of zinc solidification. It has no meaningful effect on corrosion performance, though it can slightly affect painting appearance and surface roughness.